Difference between revisions of "Help:FAQ"

From OMPwiki
(What is the difference between 'decreased phenotype X' and 'abolished phenotype X'?)
(Why not use the term 'absence of X' to describe a mutant phenotype?)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
 
The 'decreased phenotype X' would be used when a phenotype is decreased, but can still be detected.  For example, OMP:0000002 decreased cell motility would be used to describe the phenotype of a mutant strain that is less motile than the parent strain, but still retains some motility.  Either OMP:0000002 or OMP:0007000 abolished cell motility  could be used to describe the phenotype of a mutant that has no detectable motility because abolished motility is the limit case of decreased motility
 
The 'decreased phenotype X' would be used when a phenotype is decreased, but can still be detected.  For example, OMP:0000002 decreased cell motility would be used to describe the phenotype of a mutant strain that is less motile than the parent strain, but still retains some motility.  Either OMP:0000002 or OMP:0007000 abolished cell motility  could be used to describe the phenotype of a mutant that has no detectable motility because abolished motility is the limit case of decreased motility
  
== Why would you describe a complete loss as decreased X, which a child of X positive? ==
+
== Why not use the term 'absence of X' to describe a mutant phenotype?==
Example:
+
OMP uses the 'absence of X' to annotate an independent phenotype<ref name='PMID:25433798'/>, i.e. it provides information about an organism without reference to any other information.  The phenotype of a mutant strain is typically being observed as a relative difference observed between the phenotypes of at least two separate genotypes.  If a member of a newly identified bacterial taxon were observed to move, it would have the independent phenotype “presence of cell motility”. However, if a mutant strain was isolated that was less motile, then that strain would be described by the dependent phenotype “decreased cell motility,” which is relative to the strain used as a reference. An organism that was non-motile, such as Klebsiella pneumonia, would have the independent phenotype “absence of cell motility”
* decreased motility is a child of motile
 
* decreased catalase activity is a child of catalase activity
 
 
 
== Why not use the non-X term, e.g. nonmotile or catalase negative ==
 
We use terms like nonmotile and catalase negative to annotate properties of a species, while decreased motility or decreased catalase activity are used for mutants where there is less of X than in the reference strain (wt or a parent), which is motile and catalase positive.
 
  
 
== References ==
 
== References ==

Latest revision as of 19:07, 16 March 2015

What is the difference between 'decreased phenotype X' and 'abolished phenotype X'?

The 'decreased phenotype X' would be used when a phenotype is decreased, but can still be detected. For example, OMP:0000002 decreased cell motility would be used to describe the phenotype of a mutant strain that is less motile than the parent strain, but still retains some motility. Either OMP:0000002 or OMP:0007000 abolished cell motility could be used to describe the phenotype of a mutant that has no detectable motility because abolished motility is the limit case of decreased motility

Why not use the term 'absence of X' to describe a mutant phenotype?

OMP uses the 'absence of X' to annotate an independent phenotype[1], i.e. it provides information about an organism without reference to any other information. The phenotype of a mutant strain is typically being observed as a relative difference observed between the phenotypes of at least two separate genotypes. If a member of a newly identified bacterial taxon were observed to move, it would have the independent phenotype “presence of cell motility”. However, if a mutant strain was isolated that was less motile, then that strain would be described by the dependent phenotype “decreased cell motility,” which is relative to the strain used as a reference. An organism that was non-motile, such as Klebsiella pneumonia, would have the independent phenotype “absence of cell motility”

References

See Help:References for how to manage references in OMPwiki.

  1. Chibucos, MC et al. (2014) An ontology for microbial phenotypes. BMC Microbiol. 14 294 PubMed OMPwiki page